Is Milwaukee Better Than Craftsman? A Comprehensive Comparison

When you’re in the market for tools, choosing the right brand can make a big difference in the quality of your work and how long your equipment lasts. Two of the most recognizable names in the industry are Milwaukee and Craftsman. Whether you’re a seasoned professional, a DIY enthusiast, or just someone who needs reliable tools around the house, comparing these two brands will help you make an informed decision.

This article will dive into an in-depth comparison between Milwaukee and Craftsman, focusing on various factors such as build quality, performance, battery life, price, and more. By the end of this comparison, you’ll know which brand suits your specific needs best.

Overview of Milwaukee and Craftsman

Milwaukee: A Brand for Professionals

Founded in 1924, Milwaukee has built a reputation for creating high-performance, durable tools specifically designed for professionals. The brand has become synonymous with cutting-edge technology, especially in its power tools and cordless solutions. Milwaukee is well-known for tools like the M18 and M12 FUEL lines, offering excellent performance, even in harsh conditions.

Milwaukee caters primarily to tradespeople like electricians, plumbers, and contractors who need reliable tools that can handle daily, heavy-duty use. It’s a brand you’ll see on many job sites, thanks to its durability and long-lasting power. The company has also invested heavily in innovations like its One-Key system, allowing users to track, manage, and customize their tools via Bluetooth technology.

Craftsman: Accessibility and Versatility

Craftsman, established in 1927, is a brand known for offering a more budget-friendly option for homeowners and hobbyists. It’s a popular choice for those looking to tackle home improvement projects, minor repairs, and general DIY tasks. While Craftsman tools may not offer the same level of industrial strength as Milwaukee, they are recognized for their versatility and affordability.

Craftsman’s product range is extensive, covering everything from hand tools to power tools, as well as lawn and garden equipment. In recent years, Craftsman has stepped up its game by improving its quality and design, especially after its acquisition by Stanley Black & Decker in 2017, which infused new energy into the brand. One of Craftsman’s standout features is its V20 cordless system, which provides decent battery performance for a wide range of tools at an accessible price.

Head-to-Head Comparison Categories

Product Range & Specialties

When comparing Milwaukee and Craftsman, it’s crucial to look at their product ranges and unique offerings.

Milwaukee specializes in high-performance power tools. The brand is particularly known for its cordless solutions like the M18 and M12 FUEL lines, which are designed for heavy-duty, professional use. Milwaukee also focuses on trade-specific tools, such as plumbing, electrical, and mechanical equipment, which makes it the go-to brand for professionals in these industries.
Craftsman, on the other hand, offers a broader range of tools that are perfect for homeowners, hobbyists, and those who want versatility at an affordable price. While they may not match Milwaukee in terms of specialized professional tools, Craftsman provides a solid variety of hand tools, lawn and garden equipment, and affordable power tools that can handle most household tasks.

Build Quality & Durability

One of the most significant factors that professionals and DIYers consider is the durability and build quality of their tools.

Milwaukee is known for its industrial-grade materials and construction. Whether it’s a cordless drill, a saw, or an impact driver, Milwaukee tools are designed to withstand constant, rigorous use in professional environments. Their tools often come with reinforced housings, which protect them from drops, debris, and wear-and-tear, making them ideal for heavy-duty jobs.
Craftsman tools, while not as robust as Milwaukee’s, offer reliable performance for light to moderate tasks. Their build quality has improved over the years, particularly in their V20 power tool line and lawn care equipment. While Craftsman tools may not last as long under extreme conditions, they are more than sufficient for home projects and general use.

Power and Performance

When it comes to performance, both Milwaukee and Craftsman excel in different areas. Let’s break down how they measure up:

Milwaukee is well-regarded for its power tools, especially in terms of torque, speed, and consistency. The M18 FUEL series of cordless tools are some of the most powerful on the market. These tools use brushless motors for higher efficiency, resulting in better performance and longer lifespan. Milwaukee tools are often preferred by contractors because they can handle intense workloads without compromising on power. For example, Milwaukee’s cordless drills and impact drivers can handle even the toughest materials like concrete and metal.
Craftsman, while not designed for heavy-duty professional work, performs very well in the DIY and light-to-medium duty categories. Their V20 cordless system offers decent power for household projects like drilling into wood or minor renovations. The V20 line has seen significant improvements in recent years, providing sufficient power for most home users, though it doesn’t match Milwaukee’s performance in industrial settings. Craftsman’s brushless motors are also efficient but are more suited for medium-level tasks.

Battery Life and Cordless Technology

In today’s world, cordless tools are the gold standard for convenience and flexibility. Milwaukee and Craftsman both have impressive cordless tool systems, but there are clear differences in battery life and technology.

Milwaukee: One of the standout features of Milwaukee’s tools is their RedLithium battery system. These batteries are known for their long-lasting charge and fast recharge times, giving users more uptime and less downtime. Milwaukee’s battery technology is designed for professional-grade use, providing longer cycles and better performance in cold weather compared to its competitors. Moreover, Milwaukee’s One-Key system allows users to track battery life, customize performance, and even lock the tool if it gets lost or stolen—something Craftsman doesn’t offer.
Craftsman: The V20 battery system from Craftsman offers good performance for DIYers and homeowners. While it may not offer the same power output or lifespan as Milwaukee’s RedLithium batteries, it’s perfectly suitable for light-duty tasks around the home. The V20 system features interchangeable batteries across a wide range of Craftsman tools, making it convenient for users who want a reliable set of tools for general use. Craftsman tools also come with affordable, easy-to-replace batteries, making them ideal for users who prioritize cost-efficiency.

Price and Affordability

Price is often one of the biggest deciding factors when choosing between Milwaukee and Craftsman. While both brands have their unique selling points, they cater to different segments of the market.

Milwaukee: Generally speaking, Milwaukee is priced at the premium end of the market. This is because the brand is designed for professionals who need top-tier performance, durability, and technology. Milwaukee’s tools are built to last, and the price reflects this. However, for those who need tools for everyday, heavy-duty use, the investment in Milwaukee is often worth it due to their longer lifespan and better performance under pressure.
Craftsman: Craftsman is much more budget-friendly, making it an excellent choice for homeowners, hobbyists, and light-to-medium users. Their tools provide good value for the price, especially considering the improvements in their cordless tool systems and general tool range. If you’re looking for tools to use occasionally or for smaller tasks, Craftsman gives you the versatility you need without breaking the bank. Additionally, Craftsman’s warranty often includes lifetime coverage for hand tools, adding extra value for those looking for long-term reliability at an affordable price.

Warranty and Customer Support

Another important factor to consider when comparing Milwaukee and Craftsman is their warranties and customer service.

Milwaukee offers a five-year warranty on most of its power tools, which is one of the best in the industry. This warranty covers defects in material or workmanship but excludes general wear and tear. Milwaukee’s customer support is known for being responsive and helpful, especially for professional contractors who rely on their tools for business. The company’s tools are also built to last, so many users rarely need to use the warranty.
Craftsman is famous for its lifetime warranty on hand tools, which has long been a selling point for the brand. This means you can replace broken or defective tools at no cost, regardless of how long you’ve owned them. For power tools, Craftsman typically offers a three-year limited warranty, which is shorter than Milwaukee’s but still competitive in the home-use market. Overall, Craftsman’s warranty is designed to appeal to DIYers and casual users who want the assurance of long-term support without investing in expensive tools.

User Experience and Reviews

An essential part of choosing between Milwaukee and Craftsman is understanding how these tools perform in real-world scenarios. Here, we’ll look at user feedback and reviews from both professionals and DIYers to provide a balanced perspective.

Milwaukee User Feedback: Milwaukee receives glowing reviews from professionals who use their tools in demanding environments. Contractors, electricians, and mechanics often praise Milwaukee for its reliability and performance under stress. For example, users report that Milwaukee’s cordless drills and impact drivers can handle tough materials like metal, concrete, and hardwood without overheating or slowing down. Milwaukee’s M18 FUEL line is particularly well-regarded for its power and battery life, often outperforming other brands in high-stress applications. However, some users note that the premium price can be a drawback if you’re only using the tools for occasional home repairs.
Craftsman User Feedback: Craftsman, on the other hand, is frequently praised by homeowners and DIY enthusiasts for its ease of use and affordability. Many users appreciate the V20 cordless tool line for its lightweight design and flexibility, making it ideal for home improvement projects. While it doesn’t offer the same power as Milwaukee, Craftsman tools are generally regarded as perfect for light-to-medium use. The hand tools also receive high marks due to their lifetime warranty, providing users with peace of mind. However, some reviews mention that Craftsman’s tools aren’t as durable in high-stress environments, and the performance may decline with heavy use over time.

Pros and Cons of Milwaukee vs. Craftsman

To help you quickly understand the strengths and weaknesses of each brand, here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons:

Milwaukee Pros:

Durability: Milwaukee tools are built to last, especially in harsh environments like construction sites or industrial settings.
High Performance: The M18 and M12 FUEL systems are known for delivering excellent power and performance, suitable for heavy-duty tasks.
Innovative Technology: Features like the One-Key system and RedLithium batteries provide added value for professionals needing customization and tracking options.
Long Battery Life: Milwaukee’s batteries hold up under long workdays, reducing downtime for recharging.

Milwaukee Cons:

Price: Milwaukee tools tend to be on the expensive side, making them less appealing for casual users or those on a budget.
Overkill for Casual Users: For homeowners or occasional users, the power and features of Milwaukee tools may not be necessary.

Craftsman Pros:

Affordability: Craftsman offers a wide range of tools at a price point that’s accessible to most homeowners and DIYers.
Lifetime Warranty on Hand Tools: Craftsman’s hand tools come with an unbeatable lifetime warranty, ensuring long-term reliability.
Versatility: Craftsman provides tools for a wide variety of applications, from lawn care to home repair, making it a one-stop shop for many households.
Ease of Use: Craftsman tools, particularly the V20 line, are lightweight and user-friendly, ideal for smaller projects and home improvements.

Craftsman Cons:

Not as Durable: Craftsman tools are not built for heavy-duty or professional-level use and may wear out faster under constant stress.
Lower Performance: Compared to Milwaukee, Craftsman’s power tools don’t offer the same level of torque or performance, which can be limiting for tougher jobs.

Use Case Scenarios: Which Brand is Better for You?

Your choice between Milwaukee and Craftsman should depend on your specific needs. Let’s look at different use-case scenarios to see which brand may be the better fit:

For Professionals:

If you’re a contractor, electrician, or any professional who relies on your tools for daily, heavy-duty work, Milwaukee is the clear winner. The brand’s focus on durability, high performance, and innovative technology like the One-Key system makes it a top choice for professionals who need tools that can withstand constant use. Milwaukee’s cordless tools, especially from the M18 FUEL line, are designed to handle the toughest jobs with ease.

For DIYers and Homeowners:

For most homeowners and DIY enthusiasts, Craftsman is an excellent option. If you’re working on weekend projects, doing minor renovations, or handling repairs around the house, Craftsman offers the perfect balance of affordability and functionality. The V20 line of cordless tools is easy to use and provides more than enough power for the average DIYer. Plus, Craftsman’s hand tools are a great investment due to their lifetime warranty.

For Hobbyists:

Hobbyists who often work on small-scale projects but don’t need industrial-grade tools may find themselves choosing between the two brands. In this case, it’s a matter of budget versus performance. Craftsman will likely meet most of your needs at a more affordable price, but if you occasionally require more power or durability, Milwaukee might be worth the investment.

Conclusion: Is Milwaukee Better Than Craftsman?

After examining the various aspects of Milwaukee and Craftsman, it’s clear that each brand excels in different areas, making the best choice highly dependent on your needs.

Milwaukee is the go-to brand for professionals and those who need tools for heavy-duty tasks. Its tools are designed to withstand intense, long-term use, and its innovative features—like the One-Key system and RedLithium batteries—make it a reliable choice for people who need their tools to be high-performance and future-proof. However, Milwaukee’s premium pricing may not make sense for someone who only needs tools occasionally.
Craftsman stands out as an excellent option for homeowners, DIYers, and hobbyists. The brand provides tools that are affordable and versatile, perfect for home improvement projects or smaller jobs that don’t require industrial-level performance. Craftsman’s lifetime warranty on hand tools adds tremendous value, particularly for those who want reliable tools without the high price tag. However, Craftsman’s tools may not be as durable in demanding, professional settings compared to Milwaukee.

Ultimately, the answer to the question, “Is Milwaukee better than Craftsman?” depends on what you need from your tools. If you are a professional seeking durability and top-tier performance, Milwaukee is likely the better choice. But if you’re a DIYer or a homeowner looking for versatile and affordable tools for occasional use, Craftsman is hard to beat.

FAQs

Are Milwaukee tools worth the higher price?
- Yes, if you’re a professional or someone who needs tools for heavy-duty work, Milwaukee’s higher price is justified by its durability, performance, and cutting-edge features.
Is Craftsman a good brand for DIY projects?
- Absolutely. Craftsman is designed for DIYers and homeowners, offering versatile and budget-friendly tools that are ideal for smaller tasks around the home.
Can Milwaukee and Craftsman batteries be used interchangeably?
- No, Milwaukee and Craftsman batteries are not compatible with each other. Milwaukee uses the RedLithium system, while Craftsman operates on the V20 system.
Which brand offers better customer service?
- Both brands offer strong warranties and reliable customer service. Milwaukee offers a 5-year warranty on most tools, while Craftsman provides a lifetime warranty on its hand tools, making both brands dependable in terms of customer support.

For more informative posts like this, stay tuned with Do You Compare?